Inside the Saints' Quarterback Battle: Why Spencer Rattler Emerged as the Starter
Explore the detailed analysis behind the New Orleans Saints' decision to start Spencer Rattler over Tyler Shough for the 2025 NFL season.

The Quarterback Decision
First-year head coach Kellen Moore of the New Orleans Saints faced a pivotal decision in selecting the starting quarterback for the 2025 NFL season. After a rigorous three-month evaluation, Moore announced that Spencer Rattler would lead the team, edging out Tyler Shough, the No. 40 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft.
Rattler's Journey
Rattler, a second-year quarterback, demonstrated significant growth following a challenging rookie season. Despite being sacked 22 times behind an injured offensive line and witnessing the mid-season firing of then-coach Dennis Allen, Rattler's resilience and improvement were key factors in Moore's decision.
Shough's Performance
Shough, though impressive, was still finding his footing as a rookie. His ability to move the offense and his resilience in bouncing back from mistakes kept him in contention. However, Rattler's consistency and experience ultimately gave him the edge.
The Decision-Making Process
Moore emphasized the importance of taking the entire process to evaluate both quarterbacks thoroughly. The Saints analyzed practice data, game performances, and how each quarterback learned from their mistakes. Rattler's ability to rebound from challenges and his confidence in making plays were decisive factors.
Looking Ahead
With Rattler as the starting quarterback, the Saints are poised to begin a new era. This marks the first time in decades that the team will start the season with a quarterback they drafted and developed, reminiscent of the Archie Manning era in 1971.
Team Dynamics
Moore ensured that the entire team was informed of the decision before it was made public. He emphasized the importance of defining roles for everyone on the team to foster a connected and successful unit.
Rattler's Mindset
Rattler expressed his excitement and readiness to lead the team. He acknowledged the hard work and competition that brought him to this point and is focused on making the most of this opportunity.
Conclusion
The Saints' decision to start Spencer Rattler over Tyler Shough was a testament to his growth, resilience, and performance. As the team prepares for the season opener against the Arizona Cardinals, all eyes will be on Rattler to lead the Saints to success.